Waxy.org
Waxy.org is the sandbox of Andy Baio, an independent journalist and programmer living in Portland, Oregon. I created Upcoming.org and some other stuff too.

Contact Me: log@waxy.org or waxpancake on AIM

Metafilter Sources

Posted Aug 6, 2004

As part of my ongoing interest in Metafilter statistics, I was curious to see which sites Metafilter users link to the most.

From a complete dump of Metafilter's front-page post database back to July 1999 (thanks, Matt!), I extracted the unique domains linked from each entry and added them all up.

The Top 50 results are below, proving that the NewsFilter moniker isn't too far off. (Or you can view the entire list.)

Top 50 Metafilter Sources (View All...)

  1. metafilter.com (1457)
  2. news.bbc.co.uk (1218)
  3. nytimes.com (1136)
  4. cnn.com (979)
  5. dailynews.yahoo.com (828)
  6. washingtonpost.com (815)
  7. guardian.co.uk (481)
  8. story.news.yahoo.com (471)
  9. salon.com (458)
  10. msnbc.com (455)
  11. amazon.com (441)
  12. wired.com (394)
  13. geocities.com (391)
  14. sfgate.com (315)
  15. us.imdb.com (273)
  16. google.com (267)
  17. abcnews.go.com (244)
  18. boston.com (239)
  19. pbs.org (234)
  20. bbc.co.uk (224)
  21. slate.msn.com (189)
  22. latimes.com (185)
  23. newscientist.com (175)
  24. theregister.co.uk (162)
  25. foxnews.com (155)
  26. reuters.com (140)
  27. time.com (139)
  28. usatoday.com (135)
  29. cbc.ca (132)
  30. news.cnet.com (129)
  31. members.aol.com (124)
  32. theatlantic.com (119)
  33. villagevoice.com (117)
  34. newyorker.com (115)
  35. cgi.ebay.com (113)
  36. apple.com (111)
  37. slashdot.org (110)
  38. npr.org (109)
  39. ananova.com (106)
  40. whitehouse.gov (103)
  41. espn.go.com (102)
  42. smh.com.au (101)
  43. angelfire.com (99)
  44. zdnet.com (97)
  45. nandotimes.com (96)
  46. imdb.com (93)
  47. observer.co.uk (92)
  48. microsoft.com (90)
  49. memory.loc.gov (90)
  50. iht.com (85)

14 Comments (Add Yours)

Aug 6, 2004
5:15 PM  
Stewart Butterfield wrote:

I'd be interested to see the intersection of the big list with a list of blogs (from blo.gs or technorati or something?). Ctrl-Fing around revealed kottke (63), waxy.org (24), sylloge.com (16) ...

Also, if you plotted the distribution on a graph, it'd seem less newsfilter-y, I think: the 1s start at position 8,333, but there are 27,173 entries.


Aug 6, 2004
5:38 PM  
Andy Baio wrote:

Here's a chart of the results.


Aug 6, 2004
7:26 PM  
Anonymous wrote:

what hte hell good is that chart as a png? give me a zoomable dataset so i can see some more information beyond "fuck, it drops off real fast"


Aug 6, 2004
8:30 PM  
ericville wrote:

i can't imagine keeping a record of every MetaFilter post since 1999 (34,831 posts as of now? *whew*)

it's reassuring to see that it's the BBC who's getting the most hits out of all the other news sites, tho ;) ...thanks for the stats.


Aug 7, 2004
5:41 AM  
Keith TTIKTDA wrote:

This makes sense, even without 'newsfilter'

Think about it. What websites are constantly updated, on a daily basis, with things worthy of notice by a community weblog?

News sites, news sites, and umm... news sites.

Random flash movies, strange musical endeavors, weird new blogs, all tend to have their own domains.

News articles, inherently, show up on news sites, which are posting them consistently.

In other words, 10 flash movies, will come from 10 domains.

But 10 incredible, world stoppingly important news stories, will all be linked from CNN.

Newsfilter nothin'. It's just the nature of the Internet.


Aug 7, 2004
7:47 AM  
Andy Baio wrote:

The chart isn't supposed to be a good way to browse the dataset (there are over 27,000 records). It's just meant to show that the data follows a power law distribution.


Aug 8, 2004
10:13 PM  
david wrote:

Looks like I need to start updating my bookmarks :)


Aug 9, 2004
7:55 AM  
Simon wrote:

Interesting stuff. As a Brit, I'm quite proud to have two of our news sources up in the top 10, even more that the BBC is no. 1(ish). What does this mean in terms of Metafilter's readership's nationalities or political leaning? (esp. since the Guardian is a leftie, even in the UK...)


Aug 12, 2004
10:00 AM  
l y s o l wrote:

Are you just going to ignore the fact that the number one link is to metafilter itself? Power law curves are interesting, and all, but the real story is metafilter users' self-importance.


Aug 12, 2004
10:11 AM  
Andy Baio wrote:

It has less to do with self-importance, and more to do with referring back to older Metafilter threads. Whenever someone updates an older story or refers to a past thread, it's a link to Metafilter.


Aug 13, 2004
3:42 PM  
Anonymous wrote:

Not to mention every Double post callout...


Aug 22, 2004
5:57 PM  
mark wrote:

heh... apple.com ranks higher than microsoft.com


Sep 8, 2004
12:53 AM  
dabitch wrote:

heh, go beeb!


Aug 3, 2006
4:33 PM  
mrbene wrote:

BBC is prolly one of the highest through sheer laziness - default Firefox install has "Latest Headlines" RSS feed that is BBC news exclusively, and if you can find it there, why look anywhere else?


 

Leave a comment





Waxy Links
Ads via The Deck
November 18, 2008
Bike Hero, biking a Guitar Hero level in the real world — most likely a commercial viral, and maybe even fake, but does it matter? beyond awesome
Chuck Klosterman reviews Chinese Democracy — mostly posting this just to beat Rex to it
The A.V. Club's 27 popular websites that became books — though they missed Belle de Jour, The Washingtonienne, Fucked Company, Fark, and ZUG
Speed Guitar goes to the Los Angeles County Museum of Art — every hour, on the hour, for one solid minute of metal complete with gothic arch and smoke machine
MGMT's "Kids" on the iPhone Ocarina — "the iPhone Ocarina officially replaces the recorder as the nerdiest instrument I can play"
Mena Trott responds to Valleywag article about their Disneyland vacation — my favorite was Space Mountain Snob
LIFE Magazine photo archive hosted by Google — millions of high-res photos, most never published
Amazon launches CloudFront, their pay-as-you-go CDN — very complementary with S3
November 17, 2008
John Hodgman, Jonathan Coulton, and the Long Winters perform "Tonight You Belong to Me" — "Thank you, normal-sized man."
Jerry Yang stepping down from Yahoo's CEO post — it never really fit him well, though I'll miss his e.e. cummings memos
Woman asks Apple community about an unusual iPhone glitch — no, raunchy photos don't accidentally attach themselves to outbound email
Greasemonkey script to pull WikiDashboard visualization into Wikipedia — I made a LazyWeb plea for this last week, and Paul Irish came through
Lee Byron's Fireflies, anaglyph 3D game for Mac — part of Kokoromi's Gamma 3D showcase of anaglyph games
Flickr Boundaries, tool to explore Flickr's shapefiles — read Tom Taylor's entry for more information
Cooking Mama, the Unauthorized PETA Edition — a strangely obscure target for their attention, with a petition to write to the game's publisher (via)
Boing Boing launches gaming blog, Offworld — good writing in a nice design from Brandon Boyer, former news editor of Gamasutra
"Violet" wins the Interactive Fiction Comp 2008 — play it online; glancing at the charts, it looks like Buried in Shoes was the most divisive
Trailer for J.J. Abrams' Star Trek prequel — looks surprisingly good, but I'm a sucker for origin stories; I even liked Enterprise
What would Depression 2009 look like? — Tim sums up the thought-provoking Boston Globe article
The Pirate Bay hits 25 million simultaneous peers — that's not unique people, but concurrent connections; Napster peaked at 26M users
Peter Hirschberg releases Adventure as a free iPhone app — related: Chasing Ghosts will finally be released on BitTorrent Showtime in December (via)
The Big Picture on the California wildfires — also: first-person coverage on Twitter and YouTube, like this freeway on fire and aftermath
Tim-Tams available at Target until March, first time available in the U.S. — best chocolate cookies ever, the Tim Tam Slam is a chocolaty revelation (via)
JS-909, a Javascript drum machine without Flash — through a hack, it even works in IE 6
November 14, 2008
Esquire's hosting Between, the new two-player networked game by Jason Rohrer — from the creator of Passage
"What's that buzzing noise from my BBQ?" — he thought he was killing a few bees, but ends up annihilating an entire colony (via)
November 13, 2008
Kottke explains how to embed high-quality YouTube videos — I knew how to save, link, and change the default, but the embedding hack was new to me
Web 2.0 Origami — lazyweb, please build a converter that creates folding patterns from an uploaded image
Pixar's Burn-E short on YouTube — here's an interview with the director
Valleywag folded into Gawker, all but Owen Thomas laid off — I won't miss it; they hurt a lot of good people and interesting projects in the quest for pageviews (via)

Andy Baio lives here. Some rights reserved, for your pleasure.