Waxy.org
Waxy.org is the sandbox of Andy Baio, an independent journalist and programmer living in Portland, Oregon. I created Upcoming.org and some other stuff too.

Contact Me: log@waxy.org or waxpancake on AIM

Worst Website Ever, Redux

Posted Mar 9, 2008 (Updated Apr 15, 2008)

Yesterday's Worst Website Ever session was standing-room only and judging from the response, it was a hit.

Once I can get a copy of the audio from the talk, I'll upload a screencast of the entire session with the original slides. Until then, here are the descriptions of each pitch.

Jeffery Bennett, Image Search for the Blind

Image search is fundamentally broken, only allowing sighted people to use it for entertainment and research. But what about those who can't see? Jeffery shows how harnessing the collective vision of users can describe and annotate images for use by the blind.

Michael Buffington, Pressca.st

Bloggers have been used as a powerful promotional tool, but finding bloggers willing to sell themselves out for cash takes too long! Michael demonstrates a better way that combines the worst of Amazon's Mechanical Turk and PayPerPost. Upload your press release, deposit funds with Paypal, and Turkers around the globe will instantly blog about your crappy product for pennies on the dollar. Evil!

Ben Brown & Katie Spence, Happy Net Box

Facebook broke new ground in allowing developers to create applications for their website, and the OpenSocial effort took it to the next level by allowing anyone to embed applications anywhere. Ben & Katie propose a groundbreaking new open platform: allowing developers to embed the entire Internet in your webpage with a single line of code. Don't settle for a single application -- embed the whole damn thing.

David Friedman, PeopleIPO

Take yourself public with an Individual Public Offering through PeopleIPO, allowing anyone to buy or sell shares in you! Watch as your personal life events affect your stock price, but be careful not to sell a majority stake in yourself -- or you might become a slave to your shareholders.

Lia Bulaong, Sickr

The social network for contagious diseases, where online communities go viral. See who's spread chlamydia, clap, or the common cold to their social network using a convenient Facebook badge, or just try to get to the top of the leaderboard with poor hygiene and/or risky sex. Fun for the whole family!

Merlin Mann, FlockdUp

FlockdUp.com is a best-of-breed hosted solution for networking Thought Leaders. Our Enterprise-class suite of tools empowers Topic Experts, Blog Consultants, Marketing Minds, and Social Mediapreneurs to tag, profile, remix, mash-up, *and* monetize every person that they know (or claim to know -- we're not here to judge). We understand that your career is hard to explain, and most people wouldn't understand it anyway. That's why FlockdUp does the heavy lifting with robust, integrated applications for connecting you directly to the thousands of enterprising mavericks whose email addresses you've collected. That's right: Leading with Thoughts(tm). Sign-up today for very limited, private pre-Alpha at FlockdUp.com.

Lane Becker, MMOmmerce

The next generation of shopping, from the comfort of your very own fully immersive fantasy universe. Think Kozmo meets World of Warcraft: from clicks and mortar to clicks and Mordor, rampant consumerism becomes rampaging consumerism. All without leaving your desk!

The winner, as decided by guest VC/judge David Hornik, was Merlin Mann's FlockdUp, followed closely by Jeffery Bennett's Image Search for the Blind. Here's a video of Merlin's talk, courtesy of Roo Reynolds. Thank you so much to all the presenters and everybody who attended.

April 15: Jeffery Bennett's footage from the audience is now available on Vimeo. I'm waiting for the official podcast audio from SXSW, and I'll edit together a presentation with the original slides.

7 Comments (Add Yours)

Mar 9, 2008
9:57 AM  
jeffery. wrote:

thanks andy. that was fun.


Mar 9, 2008
1:41 PM  
David wrote:

I don't understand: these all look like fake satirical ideas except for Presscast, which seems like a real service. I don't get why one real, though crappy, business made it onto a list of jokes.

One criticism: this seems like a panel of internet insiders (Ben Brown ftw, naturally) exposing just how un-self-critical the industry is these days. The whole premise--gentle mockery of awfully easy targets--is really less about criticism than about a group of cool kids circling the wagons by riffing on the fun ways they thought of making money three or four years ago.

I know there's a time and place for this (and christ, if that time and place ain't SXSW then I don't know what would be), but this stuff has worn so very very thin.


Mar 9, 2008
4:24 PM  
Andy Baio wrote:

David: It wasn't intended to be deep. It was a way of entertaining a room full of geeks before we started drinking. Everybody that I've seen who actually attended (except Valleywag) said it was the best session they'd seen, everybody had a great time, and I'm pretty happy with that.

As for Pressca.st, it's Michael Buffington's form of Andy Kaufman-esque humor. Not everyone gets it, but I think it's brilliant and scary.


Mar 9, 2008
6:09 PM  
Neil K wrote:

Valleywag commenters are criticizing this session for lacking intellectual rigor. Shame on you, Andy.


Mar 14, 2008
9:52 AM  
Jg wrote:

I'm with David on this one, Andy. The session was entertaining, indeed, but I was expecting plausible ideas from the presenters -- ideas that may have had legitimate potential, if not for their poor execution, lack of proper planning, et cetera. My coworker described it as an hour-long SNL sketch, and I don't think he was all that far off. We weren't expecting deep, but we were certainly expecting something instructive or of value -- sort of a learn-from-these-people's-mistakes scenario -- and instead it felt like a lot of back-slapping and inside jokes. In other words, no offense intended, it felt like a waste of my time.


Mar 14, 2008
10:04 AM  
Andy Baio wrote:

Thanks for the feedback. It's funny, I originally intended to include a conclusion that discussed how every one of the ideas was plausible, if only they were slightly tweaked. I think it's fair to say that ideas like Image Search for the Blind, PeopleIPO, MMOmmerce, and Sickr could all be viable. Happy Net Box was baked a few years ago as Bitty Browser (Ben and Katie hadn't heard of it). Pressca.st works more as a cautionary tale; just because you can do something with existing technology, doesn't mean you should. Merlin Mann's was the only one that wasn't a real idea, but more a parody of the form.

I'm sorry you didn't get much out of it.


Mar 17, 2008
9:58 PM  
lane wrote:

jg, you're kidding, right? you've got to be kidding. please, please tell me you're kidding, or i'm going to start crying.

on a completely unrelated note: hornik has privately admitted to me that i would've been #2 if jeffrey hadn't back-handed him a $50 right before we got started. he's a vc -- is there *anything* he won't do for money? what is this world coming to?


 

Leave a comment





Waxy Links
Ads via The Deck
July 3, 2009
Sour's "Hibi no Neiro," crowdsourced music video — choreographing 64 fans with webcams (via)
Slate's Chris Wilson tracks 10,000 random YouTube URLs for 30 days — 3% hit 1,000 views, more than I would've expected (via)
Pinboard, Maciej Ceglowski's lightweight del.icio.us clone — on the roadmap: "Get acquired by Yahoo and slowly grow useless"
Donkey Kong easter egg discovered 25 years later — created by DadHacker and discovered by Don Hodges, two of my favorite gaming nerds
Newspaper Club — building a customizable newspaper printing service in 60 days; they're using InDesign as the backend
Kevin Kelly's Death Clock in Futurama — this might seem morbid to some, but I find it inspiring
July 2, 2009
Paul Lamere's Coolness Index — are female singers uncool?
Kickstarter's Big Day — 13 projects ended on July 1, raising an average 188% of their goals
Anil Dash on Malcolm Gladwell's criticism of Chris Anderson's Free — I read through Gladwell's New Yorker piece twice, and the arguments seem petty and off base
72-year-old retired boxer beats up knife-wielding knucklehead — the inane Facebook photos make this story even more delicious
July 1, 2009
Pez sues Burlingame Museum of Pez for copyright infringement — so disappointing
RIAA wins lawsuit against Usenet.com — judge rules Betamax case doesn't apply; every other Usenet provider is next
June 30, 2009
EveryBlock releases source code — it was a requirement of their funding from the Knight Foundation
Hype Machine detects cheating on charts, names names — one of the bands responds in the comments and gets schooled by Anthony (via)
Ze Frank on black, white, and shades of green — I'm loving this series
China bans gold farming, real-world sale of virtual goods — Eurogamer estimates 1 million Chinese gold farmers with worldwide trade worth more than US$10 billion annually (via)
The Pirate Bay sold to publicly-traded Swedish gaming company — Brokep's statement is delusional; being acquired will almost certainly kill the site
Michael Rubin's "Droidmaker" book now available for free download! — authoritative 518-page history of Lucasfilm, the creation of Pixar, and much more (via)
June 29, 2009
Jason Rohrer interviewed about "selling out" to make iPhone and ad games — he recently switched from free, open-source games; also, EA claims Spielberg's LMNO isn't cancelled
Nedroid's Cosby Experiment — view all 190 Cosbys
How the NYT kept their reporter's Taliban kidnapping off Wikipedia for seven months — they collaborated with Jimmy Wales directly to freeze the entry; NPR asks if it was ethical (via)
David Fincher may direct Facebook film, adapted by Aaron Sorkin — possibly starring Michael Cera or Shia LaBeouf as Zuckerberg; this sounds familiar (via)
Quarrygirl's undercover investigation of non-vegan ingredients used at L.A.-area vegan restaurants — outstanding blog reporting, with industrial food testing from 17 different restaurants and research into suppliers
June 28, 2009
James Barnett's oil paintings of landscapes from video games — looking at the paintings, I felt like I'd actually visited those locations in real-life (via)
WSJ interviews Brenda Brathwaite about "Train," a board game about the Holocaust — not all games need to be fun (via)
June 27, 2009
How Rob Manuel accidentally started a Michael Jackson moonwalk flashmob — I'm in London right now, and I've seen several massive vigils and tributes on the streets (via)
Top teams join forces to win Netflix Prize — check the leaderboard for the first score to break the 10% improvement threshold (via)
Wired on the success of Nike+ — backstory on how it works and the Hawthorne effect; simply measuring something can change its behavior (via)
June 26, 2009
Imeem to delete all user-added photos and videos, with five days' notice — with no way to back up videos at all (via)
Shnabubula's chiptune tribute to Michael Jackson — also: Virt's incredible VRC6 cover of Thriller

Andy Baio lives here. Some rights reserved, for your pleasure.