Waxy.org
Waxy.org is the sandbox of Andy Baio, a writer and tech entrepreneur in Portland, OR. I work with Expert Labs, helped build Kickstarter, founded Upcoming, made an album, and other stuff too.

Contact Me: Email, AOL IM, or follow me on Twitter.
« July 2008 | August 2008 Archives | September 2008 »

Pirating the Olympics, Then and Now

Posted Aug 12, 2008 (Updated Aug 13, 2008)

Back in 2004, I wrote about how high-quality videos from the Olympics in Athens were being digitized and posted online, in defiance of the networks and the IOC's rules.

At the time, NBC's online coverage was restrictive by today's standards — mostly highlight clips and no live video, delayed until after the events aired on TV, and required a valid credit card to verify residency in the United States.

But that was four years ago! YouTube hadn't launched yet, HD-quality streaming video on Vimeo was three years away, and BitTorrent or HDTV were only popular with early adopters.

This year, it's much improved, albeit with some caveats. NBC's official video is great quality, if you and your computer can stomach Silverlight (unavailable on non-Intel Macs). Their coverage is fantastic, though still tape-delayed. And, because of IOC regulations forbidding international distribution, NBC won't allow you to download, embed, or transcode any videos for your iPod or phone.

Is this availability enough to satiate the pirates, and what does the quality look like compared to 2004? I went poking through Usenet and some public and private BitTorrent trackers to see.

Usenet

Back in 2004, the place to go for illegal Olympic videos wasn't BitTorrent, popular trackers like Suprnova, or mainstream P2P clients. The best coverage, surprisingly, was found in the old-school Usenet binaries. It was a mish-mash of events, skewed heavily towards events with bikini-clad women, Brazilians, or bikini-clad Brazilian women, but other popular events and the opening ceremonies also showed up.

Today, the event coverage in Usenet is just as sporadic, but the quality is dramatically better. Compare the three videos below. The first is a sample from the gymnastics high bar finals from the 2004 games, followed by the same footage of Michael Phelps' win from Saturday's 400m IM final, as seen on NBCOlympics.com and a 720p HDTV rip found in Usenet.

Size Comparison (See Actual Size)

Sample Videos (right-click to download):

  • Men's Gymnastics High Bar Finals - Usenet, 2004 (25MB MPEG1)
  • Men's Swimming 400m IM Final - NBCOlympics.com, 2008 (5MB MPEG-4)
  • Men's Swimming 400m IM Final - Usenet, 2008 (15MB MPEG-4)

Here's the full list of Olympics videos currently up on Usenet, as of this evening:

Olympic Games Opening Ceremony (720p)
Football - Group A - Ivory Coast vs. Argentina Extended Highlights
Football - Group B - Netherlands vs. Nigeria Extended Highlights
Football - Round 1 Highlights
Gymnastics - Men's Qualifying - USA
Shooting - Women's 10m Air Pistol Final
Swimming - Men's 100m Backstroke Semifinals
Swimming - Men's 100m Breaststroke Final
Swimming - Men's 200m Freestyle Semifinals
Swimming - Men's 400m Individual Medley (720p)
Swimming - Men's 4x100m Freestyle Final
Swimming - Women's 100m Backstroke Semifinals
Swimming - Women's 100m Breaststroke Semifinals
Swimming - Women's 100m Butterfly Final
Swimming - Women's 400m Freestyle Final
Volleyball - Women's Preliminaries - China vs. Switzerland

Most of these are in alt.binaries.tv, but some are also posted to alt.binaries.multimedia.sports. I'll update this list at the end of next week.

BitTorrent

But the trend for this year is clear — Usenet passed the torch to BitTorrent.

A quick search on Mininova or BTJunkie returns a huge list of every video found on Usenet, plus dozens more and growing hourly. Beyond public trackers, I've seen extensive activity on several private communities. On one of them, its members compiled a list of every event and were slowly adding their own recordings to create a massive archive of Olympics video.

And this is only Day 4! It'll be interesting to see how much of the Olympics was captured, digitized, and uploaded by the end of the games.

Also interesting: If this chart from Mark Ghuneim is accurate, the thirst for pirated Olympics coverage is greatest in China.

20 comments
« July 2008 | August 2008 Archives | September 2008 »
Waxy Links
Ads via The Deck
May 21, 2012
Makies — customizable 3D printed doll creator, founded by Alice Taylor
May 20, 2012
Euphony — piano visualization built on three.js and MIDI.js, source is on Github
Paul Lamere calculates the most musical American cities, per capita — using the Echonest API and the top 50,000 artists
Endless, Nameless — Adam Cadre's new interactive fiction inspired by BBSes and old-school text adventures
Community's 8-bit episode on Hulu — chock full of retro references, from Mega Man to Minecraft
May 19, 2012
Dan Harmon on getting fired from Community — a damn shame, this guy's the soul of the show; I can't believe he only owns 10%
Benjamin Valentine's PERFECTION — submit your own to see our collective attempts (via)
Super Chemical Bros. — the classic Star Guitar video remade in Mario (via)
May 18, 2012
What Love Looks Like — the physics of relationships
io9 charts how visions of the future changed over time — tracking how near- or distant-future science fiction is, decade by decade
How Facebook hacked the NASDAQ button to push an Open Graph action — "Mark listed a company on NASDAQ"
NYT visualization of the Facebook IPO vs. historical IPOs — 60% of IPOs since 2010 have had negative returns so far (via)
May 17, 2012
Nekogames' Parameters — abstract, but shockingly good, casual RPG; figuring out the rules is part of the fun
Law & Order & Food — "you have the right to remain delicious"
Ill Doctrine on hip hop conspiracy theories — and, more critically, the rise of gangsta rap and incarceration rates
May 16, 2012
Ze Frank on finishing — unblinking inspiration
Trailer for Ed Piskor's WIZZYWIG — awesome graphic novel inspired by real-life hackers, I highly recommend buying it
May 15, 2012
Ignore Hitler — Draw Something spawns a meme; I like the meta one (via)
Austin Seraphin on learning echolocation — he's a real-life Daredevil
Mat Honan's feature on Yahoo's mismanagement of Flickr — a depressing read, especially while seeing the team release great new features
May 14, 2012
Make interviews Bunnie Huang on the end of Chumby — sad end to a promising product, I received one of the prototypes at Foo Camp in 2006
Rebecca Sugar's Singles — file under: scenarios I'd like to play in a videogame
SMBC on hell — sounds about right
GameBoy Color emulator in JS — the source is on Github (via)
60,000 Dominoes — 65 hours over eight days; the blooper reel was hypnotic (via)
OAuth Is Your Future — Dan Hon snaps some screenshots from the near future
May 13, 2012
Fracuum — winner of Ludum Dare 23; every winner is worth playing
May 11, 2012
Welcome to Life — "the Singularity, ruined by lawyers" (via)
BusinessWeek on the post-Kickstarter life of Diaspora — the founders talk about the Ilya's tragic suicide for the first time
Anachronism detection in Mad Men episodes — language studies from the person who did the frequency analysis for Downtown Abbey (via)

Andy Baio lives here. Some rights reserved, for your pleasure.