Waxy.org
Waxy.org is the sandbox of Andy Baio, a writer and tech entrepreneur in Portland, OR. I work with Expert Labs, helped build Kickstarter, founded Upcoming, made an album, and other stuff too.

Contact Me: Email, AOL IM, or follow me on Twitter.

Audio Analysis of the Beatles Multitrack Masters

Posted Oct 11, 2009 (Updated Jan 16, 2012)

While digging through Usenet, I stumbled on these three unidentified tracks that pick apart three of the Beatles' original multitrack masters, isolating and highlighting pieces from "She's Leaving Home," "A Day in the Life," and "Come Together." It's an astounding, and very listenable, glimpse into their recording process.

Update: Removed the downloads, see update below.

  • Multitrack Analysis of She's Leaving Home
  • Multitrack Analysis of A Day In the Life
  • Multitrack Analysis of Come Together

Unfortunately, I don't have any information about the source. In the "Come Together" one, they mention one of the narrators is named "Steve." Beyond that, I haven't had any luck finding where they came from. Can anyone identify them? I'd love, love, love to hear more.

Update: It's from a BBC Radio 6 program called The Record Producers, hosted by Richard Allinson and Steve Levine, that aired last month. Unfortunately, the original BBC broadcast is no longer available on their site.

January 16, 2012: I was politely contacted by Steve Levine, creator of The Record Producers, who politely asked me to remove the sound clips. The BBC was granted permission to broadcast the sensitive Beatles master recordings with strict limitations: they could license it for only seven days after broadcast, and with the condition that they actively prevent non-authorized sources from making them available.

Unfortunately, there doesn't seem to be any legal way to purchase or listen to these recordings, and likely won't for some time.

57 Comments (Add Yours)

Oct 11, 2009
3:09 AM  
Tom wrote:

It's this, right?


Oct 11, 2009
10:15 AM  
Francis wrote:

I would love to hear the tax man session.


Oct 11, 2009
10:41 AM  
Matt wrote:

Thanks Andy !


Oct 11, 2009
5:31 PM  
Patrick Nielsen Hayden wrote:

Seconding Francis. I really, really want to hear the "Taxman" part of this, referred to in the "Day in the Life" section.


Oct 12, 2009
1:09 AM  
Sugarbear wrote:

HEADPHONES,HEADPHONES,GET YOUR HEADPHONES,More fuel added to the fire of the genesis of the Beatles and of the people they surrounded themselves with. I could have listened for hours of this.thanks for bringing this to us,the fans.


Oct 12, 2009
2:48 AM  
Ian Douglas wrote:

This is amazing. I wish the BBC would let us listen to the whole programme.


Oct 12, 2009
10:29 AM  
Zac wrote:

More more more!
I could listen to this stuff for a thousand hours.


Oct 12, 2009
11:00 AM  
Jerry wrote:

There are a lot of multitrack bits on the Purple Chick editions of the Beatles albums as well.


Oct 12, 2009
11:24 AM  
Brian wrote:

If you want to know how every single Beatles song was recorded, run and get a copy of RECORDING THE BEATLES. It costs $100, but is totally worth it. You can order it from http://recordingthebeatles.com/


Oct 12, 2009
12:19 PM  
Keith wrote:

I only listened to the "she's leaving home" analysis and was quite blown away. Of course George Martin was one of the Beatles. All I can say is sit and listen to that boy bands, girl bands and learn from the masters. Thank you for posting these recordings. Wonderful stuff !


Oct 12, 2009
12:50 PM  
Emmet wrote:

This is the most enjoyable thing I've encountered in quite a while. Thank you Andy.


Oct 12, 2009
1:10 PM  
Pedro wrote:

A fascinating look into the recordings. I sure wish more were available. Thanks for sharing!


Oct 12, 2009
2:15 PM  
Edmundo wrote:

not quite as exciting, but have you seen the youtube clip Deconstructing Sgt. Peppers? awesome.


Oct 12, 2009
2:17 PM  
illnoise wrote:

i'm so tired of the Beatles, but this gave me chills.

I think this is more of a testament to how much everything better woulda sounded if they'd played it a bit looser and not overproduced everything. The recording is all so nice and clear, too bad the final is so busy and muddy.


Oct 12, 2009
3:03 PM  
Johnny wrote:

That's not Mark Kermode? Crazy, it sounds just like him...


Oct 12, 2009
5:02 PM  
Anatol wrote:

awesome stuff! thanx guys!


Oct 12, 2009
8:31 PM  
silsurf wrote:

The entire show is available via torrent.

The Record Producers The Fifth Beatle - Audio Documentary - BBC 6Music via DVB-T
1 x 120 minutes episode - 128k - MP3 - Slimoo

The Record Producers profiles a man often labelled "The Fifth Beatle" - Sir George Martin.

Richard Allinson and Steve Levine examine his work as a producer, arranger and, through his experiments with sound, technical innovator. Highlights include the first chance to hear newly restored versions of the original master tapes for Please Please Me, along with analysis of the original multi-track of Come Together.

This programme also gives Radio 2 listeners the opportunity to hear some of the Beatles most famous songs in a new way. Because of the limitations of tape machines during the 1960s, it was necessary to either record or mix various instruments and voices onto the same track. Once they'd been committed to tape there was no way of separating them. But now, through the use of revolutionary software, listeners can hear some of these parts in isolation for the very first time.

In his exclusive interview, Sir George talks about various aspects of the studio and recording process, the albums Sgt Pepper and Abbey Road, along with a number of songs, including Strawberry Fields Forever, Tomorrow Never Knows and Rain.

Audio Format : MP3
Duration Approx : 120mn
Bit rate mode : Constant
Bit rate : 128 Kbps
Channel(s) : 2 channels
Sampling rate : 44.1 KHz
Resolution : 16 bits


Oct 13, 2009
9:28 AM  
unrelated_says wrote:

The entire show is also available at http://rapidshare.com/files/292517781/The_Record_Producers_-_The_Fifth_Beatle_-_The_Extended_Cut_.mp3.html

Alas only 128kbps.


Oct 13, 2009
12:37 PM  
Ed wrote:

Awesome! Just totally Awesome!


Oct 13, 2009
3:14 PM  
golly gosh wrote:

You'll find the whole MP3 here :-

http://www.mediafire.com/?sharekey=d7d3850207f1f48895af63b7d44918aaad61dc7f2962ed58


Oct 14, 2009
6:39 AM  
Jim Myers wrote:

Does anyone know if George Martin has done a documentary like this? I would love to see (and hear).

Aside:
There was a documentary called "The Complete Beatles" from the 80's that was amazing. I keep waiting for it to be released on DVD.


Oct 14, 2009
12:42 PM  
Robbie wrote:

Yes - George Martin has done such a documentary, at least about Sgt. Pepper:

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-6327011555352513615#


Oct 14, 2009
5:36 PM  
gerard pawling wrote:

this is bogus - and chris carter of breakfast with the beatles agrees


Oct 15, 2009
12:50 PM  
Danni Collaterali wrote:

This is great, Thanx!
@Jim Myers: YouTube-User mitaka201 has uploaded all kinds of vintage documentaries, including "The Complete Beatles".
I compiled the 14 parts into an ordered playlist, watch it here: http://www.youtube.com/view_play_list?p=23AD108F9D5150C1


Oct 18, 2009
12:16 PM  
Marv The Blogger wrote:

This is brilliant! Hm... I'd love to get my hands on these stems.. how does one go about that? heh.


Oct 18, 2009
8:54 PM  
Like The Desert wrote:

@illinoise I'm one of those that rejected the Beatles when I was a kid, so I'm still always discovering the details of what the Beatles did to make amazing compositions. I love hearing stuff like this. And hearing their process is actually helping us with ours, although we are cheating and using Logic Studio and Reason 4. With the Abbey Road refills. So yeah, REALLY cheating.

Love this deconstruction stuff. Keep it coming.


Oct 19, 2009
9:28 AM  
fieldcrow wrote:

Beatle breakdown clips fantastic. thanks so much. must hear entire BBC program! only blog I've ever enjoyed. very interesting and eclectic.

and not snarky.

I'll be back.


Oct 19, 2009
1:36 PM  
101 wrote:

This is even better than pulling out the headphone jack half-way to eliminate the stereo mix! Great stuff.

George (M) was so integral, and apparently really level-headed, good influence all around. Sad to think his hearing has suffered to the point of preventing him from working on the 'Love' sessions'.

Thanks for sharing.


Oct 26, 2009
1:59 PM  
Sair wrote:

I have both versions of the George Martin Record Producers programme, held at my apple idisk storage, but they are not lossless. If you want an invite to download just let me know via email Andy. :-)


Oct 29, 2009
7:39 AM  
Andrew wrote:

Great stuff! Thanks for sharing.


Nov 13, 2009
8:00 AM  
wiz wrote:

That was GREAT...sent it on and all me old lads agree.
Thank You


Nov 15, 2009
3:39 PM  
jim dunn wrote:

WOW! just WOW! great stuff and lots of fun here. Thanks, Andy.


Nov 20, 2009
3:11 PM  
Mark M wrote:

There are a lot of great bands that I admire. However every time I hear The Beatles, it just reconfirms in my mind that they are THE GREATEST band ever. Hands down. I'm in my 50's now and I listen to a lot of modern music. But I wonder if in my life God will ever again put together 4 individuals, each bringing just the right talents in order to create musical perfection. BTY do yourself a favor and listen to listener supported radioparadise.c-m


Nov 22, 2009
1:56 PM  
uauuuuu wrote:

uauuuuu that is amazing.... Congrats for the work.


Dec 3, 2009
11:45 AM  
Kevin Smith wrote:

These guys were and are geniuses. They use what would be considered antiquated gear and produced a new standard.
That's real talent.


Dec 11, 2009
11:46 PM  
Alvaro Oliver wrote:

beautiful! thanks for hosting this.

Paul's crystal clear voice sounds amazing. Even better than the album.

Just a tip (not offtopic): if you're into music or audio production and you enjoy Beatles, you'd like to know that recently released "Beatles Rock Band" video game opened a wide amount of posibilities cause, to make that video game developers needed the multitrack sessions for all songs included in the application.
Those audio files are hard coded into the program. however, some people found the way out to decrypt these files and extract the audio wich are actually high quality MOGG (Multitrack OGG) files you can play with audacity or any software supportinf these audio format.

Just try searching for MOGG rockband. You'll find multitrack recordings for every band on rockband, guitar hero's catalog, not only Beatle's, wich are harder to find.

Second and last tip: X-Box files are much better (same amount of tracks than the source) than Wii version (just 4 tracks), while playstation is in the middle (i think it's limited to 8 tracks).

Enjoy.-

PS: sorry about my english, i'm chilean (spanish speaker)


Dec 27, 2009
10:34 PM  
Christopher wrote:

Thank you for this post... Been a huge Beatles fan since I was a kid and went to an audio engineering school in the early 90's so this is like... fantastic for me!


Dec 28, 2009
9:06 AM  
Scouser wrote:

Superb program.. Just to let everyone know this is one of a series of programmes called "The Record Producers" I think it is in its 3rd series. I have not heard them all, but everyone i have heard has been excellent. Unfortunately they are no longer availible to listen. Re other multitracks,there are a few about, I have about six beatles tracks, some Marvin Gaye & some Bob Marley stuff..


Jan 12, 2010
4:19 PM  
Dylan Stockman wrote:

This is great I love the Beatles!


Jan 12, 2010
9:55 PM  
Richard Pelletier wrote:

THANK YOU! This is such a fantastic experience. I'm with the person who said s/he could listen to this for 1,000 hours. I want Taxman!


Jan 16, 2010
11:35 PM  
Dan in Capitola wrote:

Read Geoff Emerick's book to see where the credit is due...


Feb 2, 2010
8:58 PM  
Rick S. wrote:

Many of you may already know of this... but after all the memoirs and "inside" stories of The Beatles (and I have read quite a few also) THIS one is truly one of the BEST... because it's about the lads in their element, the one we care MOST about -- therecording studio. And it's written by the man who was there and shares firsthand knowledge of the experiences, Geoff Emerick. A must read!! "Here There and Everywhere: My Life Recording the Music of The Beatles"

http://www.amazon.com/Here-There-Everywhere-Recording-Beatles/dp/1592401791


Feb 24, 2010
11:39 AM  
Mary wrote:

This is awsome...I just love "she's leaving home"....thank You Andy.


Jul 2, 2010
11:03 PM  
Schprocket wrote:

@ Mary

I agree, the harp and violins at the start of the "She's Leaving Home" clip are stunning.

However, I do find it hard to determine any 'best' track from the above. I started out with "Come Together" as my fave of the three (at the moment :) ) but in the end I'm just left floored by them all.

I've been learning how to record and mix myself (a teenage dream which lay dormant for 30-odd years) and I find the whole process fascinating and insightful from that perspective as well.


Jul 15, 2010
1:42 PM  
Kathleen wrote:

This is so fantastic. It's very cool to listen to how The Beatles made their magic. Thank you so much Andy.


Sep 30, 2010
9:30 AM  
Thom wrote:

Talk about having your ears opened.

What a TREAT! Thank you!


Jan 5, 2012
3:00 PM  
Gail Jane Schwartz wrote:

Fantastic! I would LOVE to hear more.


Jan 5, 2012
4:39 PM  
ctmartin wrote:

Me too!!! Me too!!!!!!

Very cool. I'm so glad someone resurrected this blog post 'cause I missed it the first time around.


Jan 6, 2012
11:05 AM  
Peter J. Yianilos wrote:

This is fantastic stuff, for musicians and music-lovers alike.

I had the very, very good fortune to work on a recording with George Martin. Even in our brief time together, his genius was obvious. He was utterly non-controlling, open to anything, and yet at the end of the day it was obvious he had the vision and he effortlessly encouraged those around him to help accomplish it. It was a life lesson for me as a burgeoning music engineer and, eventually, producer.

The Beatles found their soulmate in George Martin, who shared their fearlessness and tremendous imagination to use every last tool in the box. Technology had nothing to do with their brilliance, if anything it was a hindrance. They were exceptional musicians, peerless composers, and with George Martin, never took no for an answer.


Jan 6, 2012
6:09 PM  
David wrote:

I'm going to say that I think that it was not George playing rhythm guitar on Come Together but John, in spite of what the narrator says. It's sounds like John's style,and at that point, they were hardly a band, so why would John have George play a part he could easily do himself.


Jan 7, 2012
5:09 AM  
Wayne wrote:

Though I certainly understand what David is saying about John having George play instead of himself, I do know that the track sheets created during Beatles sessions were meticulously kept by engineering room assistants. If George did in fact play those parts, I can think of no one on Earth that could have channeled John Lennon's guitar style better than George.


Jan 7, 2012
10:52 AM  
Rick Kempiak wrote:

Very ineresting. Sent this link to Alan Parsons who was an engineer for the Beatles.


Jan 7, 2012
12:17 PM  
Joel Melcosky wrote:

Brilliant! I highly recommend the mediashare link posted above.


Jan 15, 2012
10:04 PM  
rick gordon wrote:

I have to laugh when I think of the incredible weight that George martin was carrying each time he bounced several tracks together to make room for more playing and singing.

I can remember how I agonized over each time I had to bounce tracks on my four track cassette Tascam Porta Studio in 1982, as if the world depended on my getting it right. LOL!

I can't put into words how thrilling it is to hear the naked voice of Paul McCartney blending with John Lennon's reverb-soaked voice in "She's Leaving Home".

Every one of these new discoveries is the equivalent of deciphering the Rosetta Stone, and I am incredibly grateful to have lived long enough to hear this stuff. My thanks to Andy Baio for unearthing and especially for sharing these priceless pieces of music history! Not to be too greedy, but is it possible that we might be treated to more of these any time soon?


Jan 16, 2012
2:36 AM  
Bill Mc wrote:

How sublime to here those tracks separated like the strands of beautiful memories they evoke.

thanks to whomever produced this and a dear friend how sent me this link


Jan 16, 2012
6:46 AM  
Rob Phillips wrote:

Amazing....and no click-track!!!


Jan 21, 2012
1:58 PM  
yoav wrote:

do anyone have this downloaded? i have to have this!!
thanks


 

Leave a comment





Waxy Links
Ads via The Deck
May 21, 2012
Makies — customizable 3D printed doll creator, founded by Alice Taylor
May 20, 2012
Euphony — piano visualization built on three.js and MIDI.js, source is on Github
Paul Lamere calculates the most musical American cities, per capita — using the Echonest API and the top 50,000 artists
Endless, Nameless — Adam Cadre's new interactive fiction inspired by BBSes and old-school text adventures
Community's 8-bit episode on Hulu — chock full of retro references, from Mega Man to Minecraft
May 19, 2012
Dan Harmon on getting fired from Community — a damn shame, this guy's the soul of the show; I can't believe he only owns 10%
Benjamin Valentine's PERFECTION — submit your own to see our collective attempts (via)
Super Chemical Bros. — the classic Star Guitar video remade in Mario (via)
May 18, 2012
What Love Looks Like — the physics of relationships
io9 charts how visions of the future changed over time — tracking how near- or distant-future science fiction is, decade by decade
How Facebook hacked the NASDAQ button to push an Open Graph action — "Mark listed a company on NASDAQ"
NYT visualization of the Facebook IPO vs. historical IPOs — 60% of IPOs since 2010 have had negative returns so far (via)
May 17, 2012
Nekogames' Parameters — abstract, but shockingly good, casual RPG; figuring out the rules is part of the fun
Law & Order & Food — "you have the right to remain delicious"
Ill Doctrine on hip hop conspiracy theories — and, more critically, the rise of gangsta rap and incarceration rates
May 16, 2012
Ze Frank on finishing — unblinking inspiration
Trailer for Ed Piskor's WIZZYWIG — awesome graphic novel inspired by real-life hackers, I highly recommend buying it
May 15, 2012
Ignore Hitler — Draw Something spawns a meme; I like the meta one (via)
Austin Seraphin on learning echolocation — he's a real-life Daredevil
Mat Honan's feature on Yahoo's mismanagement of Flickr — a depressing read, especially while seeing the team release great new features
May 14, 2012
Make interviews Bunnie Huang on the end of Chumby — sad end to a promising product, I received one of the prototypes at Foo Camp in 2006
Rebecca Sugar's Singles — file under: scenarios I'd like to play in a videogame
SMBC on hell — sounds about right
GameBoy Color emulator in JS — the source is on Github (via)
60,000 Dominoes — 65 hours over eight days; the blooper reel was hypnotic (via)
OAuth Is Your Future — Dan Hon snaps some screenshots from the near future
May 13, 2012
Fracuum — winner of Ludum Dare 23; every winner is worth playing
May 11, 2012
Welcome to Life — "the Singularity, ruined by lawyers" (via)
BusinessWeek on the post-Kickstarter life of Diaspora — the founders talk about the Ilya's tragic suicide for the first time
Anachronism detection in Mad Men episodes — language studies from the person who did the frequency analysis for Downtown Abbey (via)

Andy Baio lives here. Some rights reserved, for your pleasure.