Waxy.org
Waxy.org is the sandbox of Andy Baio, an independent journalist and programmer living in Portland, Oregon. I created Upcoming.org and some other stuff too.

Contact Me: log@waxy.org or waxpancake on AIM

Yahoo's Contextual Ads in the Wild

Posted Feb 28, 2005

So, I think I have a scoop. I've discovered that Yahoo is very quietly testing their new contextual advertising program for blogs and other small publishers, a la Google Adsense.

Ken Rudman is a product manager at Yahoo-owned Overture, and his blog features contextual Overture ads throughout. His homepage shows the vertical two-ad format, monthly archives show a three-ad horizontal format, and individual entries show another variation of the horizontal format. The ads have decent relevancy, especially considering its early state.

The Javascript that generates the ad IFrame is hosted on Overture's server. The domain name refers to "ypn," which might be an acronym for the ad program... Yahoo Publishing Network, maybe?

I haven't spoken to Ken yet, but I'm assuming that only Yahoo employees are able to test the ads for now. If you find any other sites testing them, please let me know.

Update: As Phil points out, some of the ads aren't very relevant.

March 8, 2005: The program will be called the Yahoo! Publisher Network. I was close! Silicon Valley Watcher independently confirms that YPN is Yahoo's response to Google Adsense. No word on the launch date yet, but the markets have responded positively to the Yahoo rumors.

Here's another Yahoo employee blog with the same YPN ads (thanks, Rick). Oh, and anyone want to bet that their new "publishing tools" refers to a free hosted blog service that ties into their contextual ads? Brace yourselves, Blogger.

40 Comments (Add Yours)

Feb 28, 2005
5:08 PM  
Myles wrote:

Here's hoping that this competition results in higher revenue sharing with the publishers.


Feb 28, 2005
6:54 PM  
Scott Johnson wrote:

And along with the hopes of higher revenue sharing, I'd like to add that I'm hoping this competition will bring communication about percentages of revenues being shared.


Feb 28, 2005
7:32 PM  
Myles wrote:

While we're asking for ponies, I'd like to see real-time stats as well.


Feb 28, 2005
7:34 PM  
Yoki wrote:

I hope you don't mind a bit of self linkage - but here's a bit of a heads-up on what this actually is: http://www.10two.com/blog/2005/03/yahoos-adsense-or-is-it.html


Feb 28, 2005
8:20 PM  
Andy Baio wrote:

Yoki: The Citysearch ads, and other Content Match ads, are served from cmhtml.overture.com. These new ads, located at ypn.overture.com, are definitely something new. I can say with 100% certainty that it's not just Content Match, even if the end result displays similarly.


Feb 28, 2005
8:42 PM  
Yoki wrote:

Andy: good point, well made; I've updated my post accordingly. However, I don't think the technology is new. I do wonder why Yahoo/Overture have left it so long before opening this up to all publishers.


Mar 1, 2005
6:44 AM  
Éric Baillargeon wrote:

Tobacco product in the ad ? Seem Yahoo going on some niche Google have refuse to go !


Mar 1, 2005
8:15 AM  
AiK wrote:

It will be very nice if Yahoo will provide more accurate stats than current Overture Keyword Selector tool. But it sounds too good to be truth, no?


Mar 1, 2005
8:19 AM  
dave bug wrote:

It's a minor point, but how hard would it be for programmers to add a / after br tags to make them xhtml compliant?


Mar 1, 2005
1:30 PM  
David Jacobs wrote:

I bet they're going to roll out second quarter, along with an Overture name change:
http://biz.yahoo.com/ap/050301/yahoo_overture_2.html


Mar 1, 2005
3:45 PM  
Brian wrote:

Well, the ads appear to have good context from here. I mnean, really, have you seen what's advertised to the right of this page? :)


Mar 1, 2005
4:02 PM  
Ron wrote:

Yahoo’s network will undoubtedly rise to the number two position if/when it’s released for small publishers. I agree that things will improve for publishers, but will this spread ad buyers money to thin and lower costs?


Mar 2, 2005
12:00 AM  
John Wehr wrote:

Good for advertisers - bad for publishers. By decreasing the depth of the advertiser pool (effectively splitting it while opening new venues) text ad prices will drop in the short run.


Mar 2, 2005
7:00 AM  
Suzie wrote:

It will be good to see some good competition to google's monopolised Adsense.I hope it helps the publishers.


Mar 2, 2005
10:33 AM  
Planton wrote:

the post from the yahoo guy is more than a year old.... when do you belive the testing is done?


Mar 2, 2005
10:45 AM  
Rick Gagliano wrote:

This is great news for webmasters who use Adsense. A little competition will be GOOD. There's a discussion which stemmed from this blog (the link was taken down by a MOD, something about no links to blogs) at webmasterworld. Here's the link.


Mar 2, 2005
11:59 AM  
Andy Baio wrote:

Planton: His blog has been around for a while, but the ads were only added very recently.


Mar 2, 2005
10:39 PM  
CompanyRegistration wrote:

Competition will be good for everyone


Mar 3, 2005
2:14 PM  
Pete wrote:

Wow, the targetting on the individual entry (players cigarettes) is quite off.


Mar 4, 2005
9:29 AM  
Neo wrote:

Finally a long needed alternative. Google arrogance and greed is unspeakable. Who said "Make no evil"???

Now they have to change their bad attitude and start thinking for publishers who make their money, not just for themselves. Hope the Overture service would be available very soon and will serve very relevant contextual ads.


Mar 5, 2005
2:08 AM  
Christoph wrote:

Great to see this... thanks for it...
I am looking forward to test the YPN service ASAP

cheers,christoph c. cemper


Mar 7, 2005
12:47 AM  
Peter wrote:

Google just closed my AdSense account. My router is unsecured network with the name of my site .com so I can "advertise" with the residents of my building.

I guess they detected that I login to my account from the same IP people used to connect to the Internet and click on the AdSense words.

On top of that, s.o. clicked 600 times on the ads which is what I think really did it for my account.

I have no hope they will reinstate my account. Reading blogs, it seems that Google are indeed ARROGANT.

For my case, how simple would it be for them not to pay for clicks made from an IP address used to login to an account with them? Pretty simple, eh?

Also, why simply not count the clicks made in exsess from that one IP that clicked 600 times? I know they did not count them as the balance that days was $8.

The way they declare a publisher fraud and just cut off their account is the unreal...

Cheers,
P.


Mar 7, 2005
6:15 AM  
Andy Baio wrote:

While I don't consider their actions unreasonable, it's disturbing how effective it would be to get your competitors' accounts shut down by faking fraudulent activity.


Mar 7, 2005
7:35 AM  
midnight wrote:

Overture's now called Yahoo. They're re-branding all of current services under Overture to "Yahoo Search Marketing Solutions" so it's good not to see them as separate entities.

Also, although AdSense tends to have higher clickthrough rates, Yahoo's content matching does have better reporting capabalities. Gotta give it to them for being ahead of the competition on that point.

I guess my confusion with this post is the big differentiation being made between content matching and contextual advertising? Yahoo's content matching IS contextual; it's keyword driven as well as content driven (text relevant to the original search term is found in the text).


Mar 8, 2005
4:34 AM  
xStylezx wrote:

Hmmm,yahoo to do contextual huh,could prove to be interesting.


Mar 8, 2005
8:55 PM  
Rick wrote:

Another one?

http://wdr1.com/blog/


Mar 9, 2005
6:59 AM  
midnight wrote:

so it's valid.


Mar 22, 2005
6:50 AM  
Iliqn paskalev wrote:

Christoph, I had problem with google adsense too ....for few days someone used bot and clicked many times on my ads and they closed my account with reason "bad clicks" I asked for report but the answer was "in trying to protect our advertisers we can't share such details to our publishers...."
And from that day I can't apply for google adsense never more ... and this only because someone made that against me :( I tried to apply with another sites for google adsense program but no result ... when someone go in the blacklist can't apply more .....

I hope yahoo will be good for publishers ....


Apr 2, 2005
2:42 AM  
rob wrote:

I didn't even have to do anything and those ads are blocked. Go go aggressive Adblock definitions!


Apr 6, 2005
7:25 PM  
Petr wrote:

I tried AdWords a few months before but in my report was displayed a few clicks but no money :o) Has anyone this experience?


Apr 12, 2005
7:56 PM  
Web Designer India wrote:

Hey there,

Nice scoop. I've been hoping that Yahoo will come up with something of this sort for quite some time now. Google does need some good competition, and fast, to make things more exciting in this arena and to let us publishers have some good options as well.


Apr 23, 2005
12:44 AM  
Toronto Books wrote:

still not released? anyone know when Yahoo is going to be open?...wondering if they are waiting for MSN to show their stuff?


Apr 25, 2005
9:16 PM  
Writing.Com wrote:

Having 3 major 'players' in this arena would be a grand thing for online publishers. Here's hoping Yahoo! and MSN can get their products released sooner, rather than later. :-)


Jun 18, 2005
9:31 PM  
BashAnything wrote:

Google cancelled our AdSense account as well. Bogus if you ask me. What is to stop a competitor from clicking like mad on your site and getting your account canned! Any update as to when Yahoo will be coming out?


Jun 25, 2005
9:59 AM  
Online Guy wrote:

Adsense has gone into the shitter over the past year. With all other variables remaining the same basically, our per-click revenue has gone from a $1 on average to less than a dime. Indeed many times I'll see stats like: 3 clicks, $.09 total revenue.

It's not even worth the bother running adsense anymore. We are looking at alternatives.


Sep 20, 2005
9:33 AM  
Vishnu wrote:

My google adsense disabled, now a bidvertiser.. i hate it, not calculating clicks... i hope for yahoo...
Does anyone knows about msn ads ???


Sep 22, 2005
10:31 PM  
Neiq wrote:

YPN or Yahoo Publisher Network (beta)is out and I was invited to join. To help webmasters I created a ypn forum YPNhut.


Dec 8, 2005
12:48 PM  
JT wrote:

It is going to be good to see. With MSN also coming out with their vesion, the competition should be better for all of us!


Mar 7, 2006
9:46 AM  
YouDee wrote:

Damn. This is like a year ago and there's still nothing right? That's more than a little slack. Haha.


Apr 29, 2007
6:21 PM  
BadSense wrote:

Google, the self appointed Internet information disseminator and filterer adds a new benchmark to its greedy business model. Google keeps yelling about giving their advertisers and ofcourse "themselves" the ultimate selling experience at the cost of publishers. However, they have now gone a step further in making their "search user" a victim of their advertising greed.

The new light background color of the Google ads which have replaced the green background ads are now making unsuspecting users click on them thinking they are top results produced by the "Saintly Google". Nice ! Have a look at the faint color on the top right corner mentioning the "sponsored ads". Wow... while publishers now have to sport the huge "Ads by Google" logo on their sites, the common user doesn't see Google proclaim the same in large bold text. Why? Simply because the Big G wants to make the most of their own direct revenue at the users cost.

So now, the common user who made Google popular is being used as a pawn to increase advertising revenue. Even the top 10 results for a keyword like "mortgage" are actually high paying Google adwords advertiser. Sweet!

This, in my opinion is the biggest click fraud by Google. Google is making a fool out of both publishers and users.

Why should users be subject to ads with the light background? Why has the green background color been replaced? Its time to stop the masquerade.

Eagerly awaiting YPN.


 

Leave a comment





Waxy Links
Ads via The Deck
January 6, 2009
The Perils of Zero-Gravity Videography — Matt Harding discovers hard drive-based camcorder don't work in zero-gravity (via)
Screenshot: 4chan hacks MacRumorsLive during Apple keynote — the 4chan thread shows how they found the admin interface, password hashes, and finally cracked a user's password
January 5, 2009
xkcd's Guide to Converting to Metric — even Liberia and Myanmar are mostly metric, compared to the U.S.
Crowdsourcing an Ethical Dilemma — Dolores Labs uses Mechanical Turk to answer the Trolley Problem
January 3, 2009
Stamen's Mike Migurski on extreme programming vs. interaction design — the linked interview is great
January 2, 2009
Jason Scott on the closure of AOL's online communities — like physical evictions, there need to be laws protecting community data in the event of closure
JPG Magazine to stop publishing, turn off website — with only three days notice; here's the response from Derek and the JPG community
December 31, 2008
Wikipedia over DNS — loony hack serves summaries of Wikipedia articles; also available as JSON and JS
Leap year bug caused every 30GB Zune to crash at 2am this morning — as strange as the Android bug that ran every keystroke as root
Metafilter's exhaustive tour of the early origins of Adult Swim — the Cartoon Network breathed new life into old cartoons, while constantly trying to find the next big thing
December 30, 2008
Infochimps' massive scrape of Twitter's friend network — Twitter gave their blessing on sharing the 56-million records, which includes 10M tweets and 220k hashtags
The Lonely Island's We Like Sportz — the sequel to Just 2 Guyz
Niall Kennedy documents the undocumented Google Reader API — whoops, this was three years ago; here's an updated version
Sakurako Shimizu's Waveform Jewelry — the "I Do" wedding band and Atari chip ring are cute, too
Fimoculous' 30 Most Notable Blogs of 2008 — an incredibly well-researched list, with related recommendations for every entry
December 29, 2008
DJ Earworm's United State of Pop 2008 — mashing up the top 25 singles of the year into a single song and video
Twit 4 Dead, four Twitter bots fight zombies in real-time — watch their collected activity here
Facebook sentiment mining predicts presidential polls — like StateStats, Facebook Lexicon is tons of fun
Giganews reports Usenet upload growth since 2001 — note this doesn't reflect Usenet popularity, but most likely the rise of huge Blu-Ray and HD rips
December 28, 2008
List of Starbucks employee jargon — culled from the Starbucks Gossip blog
December 27, 2008
Rocketboom covers the history of the Lip Dub — the Know Your Meme series is consistently well-researched and fun to watch
Jennifer 8. Lee on the history of General Tso's Chicken — different cultures each localized their own versions of Chinese food around the world (via)
Top 20 freeware games released by Cactus, this year — is Jonatan the most prolific game developer alive?
December 26, 2008
Paul and Storm finish their 25 Days of Randy Newman — hosted on Bandcamp, and now with the solo piano track used in each song
AutoPager, infinite scrolling for Firefox — love the idea, but too clunky for everyday use (via)
December 24, 2008
Net Cafe archives, dot-com nostalgia TV show from 1996-2002 — Sergei Brin in 2000 at the newly-opened Metreon, Mondo 2000 and Boing Boing, awkward Webby broadcasts, and hundreds of dead dot-coms (via)
The Offworld's best indie and overlooked games of 2008 — also: Gamasutra's top 5 indie games
Left 4k Dead — lo-fi zombie shooter in 4k of Java (via)
NORAD's Santa Tracker on Twitter — they just passed through Kazakhstan; also tracking on Google Maps and in 3D on Google Earth
December 22, 2008
ScummVM adds support for 7th Guest — I didn't realize they expanded into non-Scumm engines last year, including the Sierra AGI games

Andy Baio lives here. Some rights reserved, for your pleasure.